09/28/00
By Daniel Klein
Journal staff writer
The presidential election is over and the winner is - George
W. Bush.
At least at New Jersey City University.
Yesterday, students playing the roles of the four
better-known presidential candidates took part in "The
Great Debate" at the school's Michael B. Gilligan Student
Union Building. The event was moderated by TV journalist Gil
Noble, who serves as a visiting specialist at the university.
"It was a great experience and I had a lot of fun,"
said Renata Moreira, an NJCU junior, whose tongue-in-cheek
portrayal of George W. won raves from the audience. "It was
a little stretch for me to be George W. It was a little
sadistic, actually," said the psychology major.
But in a twist that harkens back to the elections of 1876 and
1888, the winner of the debate's popular vote did not win in the
electoral college.
Suzanne Kabrt, who portrayed consumer advocate Ralph Nader,
ran ahead of the field with 100 votes from the audience. Moreira
garnered 90 votes as Bush.
Kabrt, a senior from Bayonne, said it's a shame Nader doesn't
have as much to spend as Gore and Bush. If he did, "he'd
give them a run for their money."
Phillip Chance, a junior at NJCU from Richmond, Va., put his
skills as a theater major to work, portraying Vice President Al
Gore, and received 56 votes.
"It wasn't really hard for me. I'm going to vote for
Gore anyway. I believe in the issues he stands for," Chance
said.
Brian Kelley, another senior from Bayonne, played the
ultra-conservative Pat Buchanan, scoring 40 votes from the
audience.
"Buchanan is an individual with a very controversial
view of the world, and he has helped me to see that there are
still too many who wish to suppress society."
To make the contest resemble an actual election, the
candidates were scored in two sections, according to Walter
Glospie, an NJCU English professor and one of the committee
members who helped organize the event.
"The popular vote from the audience made up 40 percent
of total," Glospie said. "Judges from the 'electoral
college' rated the candidates on their debating skills."
The candidates played to a packed house of students, faculty
and staff, some bedecked with white boater hats and signs for
their favorite candidates.
The debate consisted of an opening round of statements, a
round of rebuttals and then questions from the audience.
During the debate, the candidates traded barbs on the issues.
After Chance and Moreira spoke on their pro-choice stands on
abortion, Kabrt reminded them that Gore and Bush were both
against abortion during their careers.
Kelley, as Buchanan, also reiterated his quote from an
address at Bob Jones University.
"Homosexuality is the love that will not shut up,"
he said, citing Buchanan's perception that the growing
acceptance of homosexuality is part of the moral decline in
America. Kelley, in reality, is president of the university's
gay and lesbian association.
Students enjoyed the event as much as the debaters.
"I voted for Bush," said Trinity Martinez, 25, of
Kearny. "I think Renata totally captured his essence,
dodging every question thrown at her. She really was Bush. I'd
never really vote for him, though."